“I’ll Never Forget That Face”
The Temple Inn of Court program “I’ll Never Forget That Face . . . ” on the challenges of and strategies for success in criminal cases involving witness identification was held on March 14 at Temple University Beasley School of Law.
Jules Epstein, Associate Professor of Law at Widener University School of Law in Delaware was featured speaker. At the beginning of the program, a “crime” was enacted and the attendees were then asked to recount full description of the perpetrator. The exercise demonstrated just how difficult it is to fully “take in” a person’s identifiable characteristics. How does this affect justice? Quite a lot.
I had the honor of serving on the March 2012 Team that planned this program, led by Hon. M. Teresa Sarmina and attorney Stephen G. Harvey along with sixteen other members of the Inn.
Special thanks to Professor Epstein, the planning committee and the law school administration staff, especially Mary McGovern. Thanks also to Roger J. Dennis, Founding Dean and Provost of the Earle Mack School of Law at Drexel University, Dr. Mark Greenberg, Provost and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs also of Drexel.
About The Temple Inn of Court and American Inns of Court:
The Temple Inn of Court is a chapter of the American Inns of Court. The Temple Inn has the distinction of being the 100th Inn in the country and the first in Pennsylvania and recently celebrated its 20th anniversary.
From the national organization’s website: The American Inns of Court (AIC) are designed to improve the skills, professionalism and ethics of the bench and bar. An American Inn of Court is an amalgam of judges, lawyers, and in some cases, law professors and law students. Each Inn meets approximately once a month both to “break bread” and to hold programs and discussions on matters of ethics, skills and professionalism.
Looking for a new way to help lawyers and judges rise to higher levels of excellence, professionalism, and ethical awareness, the American Inns of Court adopted the traditional English model of legal apprenticeship and modified it to fit the particular needs of the American legal system. American Inns of Court help lawyers to become more effective advocates and counselors with a keener ethical awareness. Members learn side-by-side with the most experienced judges and attorneys in their community.
An American Inn of Court is not a fraternal order, a social club, a course in continuing legal education, a lecture series, an apprenticeship system, or an adjunct of a law school’s program. While an AIC partakes of some of each of these concepts, it is quite different in aim, scope, and effect.
American Inns of Court actively involve more than 25,000 state, federal and administrative law judges, attorneys, legal scholars and law students. Membership is composed of the following categories:
- Masters of the Bench – judges, experienced lawyers, and law professors
- Barristers – lawyers with some experience who do not meet the minimum requirements for Masters
- Associates – lawyers who do not meet the minimum requirement for Barristers
- Pupils – law students.
The suggested number of active members in an Inn is around 80.
Most Inns concentrate on issues surrounding civil and criminal litigation practice, and include attorneys from a number of specialties. However, there are several Inns that specialize in:
- criminal practice
- federal litigation
- tax law
- administrative law
- white-collar crime
- intellectual property
- family law
- employment and labor law
The membership is divided into “pupillage teams,” with each team consisting of a few members from each membership category. Each pupillage team conducts one program for the Inn each year. Pupillage team members get together informally outside of monthly Inn meetings in groups of two or more. This allows the less-experienced attorneys to become more effective advocates and counselors by learning from the more-experienced attorneys and judges. In addition, each less-experienced member is assigned to a more-experienced attorney or judge who acts as a mentor and encourages conversations about the practice of law.